The autumn that I started sixth grade, someone dumped off three puppies and a kitten in the ditch about half a mile from our house. The crops had already been harvested and the fields prepared for winter, so it was sheer happenchance that my father walked along the field that day and found them. He brought them home, and it was my responsibility to care for them.
The biggest of the puppies was all black, and he was a doofus. The middle puppy was black with a white bibb, and he was the smartest. The little one was a girl, all black, and much more fragile than her brothers.
I made food for them every morning before school and as soon as I came home after school, and I spent all the daylight hours that I wasn't at school outside, playing with them. I adored them.
Then one day, my mother told me that she had told my uncle to take two of them to the animal pound in town in two days. I could choose one of them to keep.
I knew what that meant, at that time and in that place. They would be gassed to death.
How could I choose who would live and who die? I loved them all, even though I loved one more than the others. But how could I choose death for two of them?
I decided I would let the choice be made for me. On the day it was to be done, I sat in my classroom and saw snow falling outside the window. I knew then that, for the rest of my life, I would think if those condemned, terrified, puppies every time it snowed.
That afternoon, when I stepped off the school bus, I was amazed and overjoyed to see not just one, but three, puppies running to greet me. It was the happiest moment of my life.
I didn't say anything to my mother, because to ask her for something was to ensure that one would not receive it. To draw her attention to something was to risk having it taken away.
It snowed a lot, and the puppies and I played and played. I dug us a snow cave in a drift, and I pulled them around on the sled. I was so very happy.
A few days later, I came home and no puppies greeted me at the school bus.
I went to my mother, and asked her where the puppies were. She told me my uncle had taken them to the pound. I said, "But I thought I was going to be allowed to keep one." She said, "You didn't choose, so I told him to take all three."
So, I failed even the one I might have saved.
And every time it snows, I remember those three puppies, and I grieve for them.