Nutrition & Diet New study: Replacing dairy products with unfortified PB alternatives.

Andy_T

Little green mod
Staff member
Joined
Dec 20, 2014
Reaction score
6,394
Location
Hannover, Germany
Lifestyle
  1. Vegan
Hello all,

I was just made aware that there is a new "horror" study making the rounds on Facebook and British Tabloids, that there has been a study performed by the University of Surrey and Queen’s University Belfast and published in Lancet Planetary Health.

Of course, when the title of the study gets re-packaged on Facebook, they tend to drop the attribute "unfortified" from plant-based alternatives, and "could lead to deficiencies in certain nutrients" immediately becomes "could be putting your health at risk" ...

For us, it will be, of course, interesting how we can counter this horror story when it will start invading all spaces shortly....

Here is a link to the original study:
 
Of course, this is in the UK, and the main deficiency of an important nutrient in the study is IODINE.

I researched that and found out that the UK decided to not make it mandatory to add iodine to salt, like many other countries did, because the British population already consumed enough iodine from milk.

And why is there iodine in milk?

As nature intended it, farmers use iodine washes to disinfect cows‘ udders, and also add iodine as supplement to cattle feed.

So every vegan who is now scared should pick up table salt with added iodine the next time they go shopping…
 
@Andy_T I vaguely remember reading something about the "goiter belt": there is an area of the U.S. where the soils tend to be deficient in Iodine, and folks in that area tended to have that condition. But these days, I don't think that many people are restricted to eating locally grown food, so I don't know if health authorities are concerned about that. Google time....


This article mentions an estimated prevalence of about 1.3-2.5% in working-age adults.
 
Last edited:
I have heard about similar areas in Europe, e.g. alpine regions in Switzerland, Southern Germany and Austria. And yes, it should not be that much of a problem nowadays. Austria (since 1963) and Switzerland (since 1922) have been legally requiring table salt producers to add iodide to their products as a countermeasure.

Goiter is no fun.

1793996129844.jpeg
 
@Emma JC I just googled about wakame, and the pix alone (in the Wikipedia entry) practically made me drool. The article did mention it as a rich source of Iodine.

Edited to add: Aaaaand I STILL think "peanut butter"- not "plant based"- every time I read "pb" or "PB".
 
Last edited:
Wakame is miraculous. I need to eat more of it. A local ramen place dumps in a bundle with their veggie ramen (to which I demand added tofu).

I use some salt when I make hummus musabaha, so hopefully I'm getting iodine there as well. I've never shown a deficiency.
 
Wakame is miraculous. I need to eat more of it. A local ramen place dumps in a bundle with their veggie ramen (to which I demand added tofu).

I use some salt when I make hummus musabaha, so hopefully I'm getting iodine there as well. I've never shown a deficiency.

just be careful as it is easy to eat too much of it and that isn't good either - I buy it in bulk from one of the local restaurants and so it is dried and in small pieces - I only put about 10 of the small pieces in my soup - I googled it also to see what you saw and those dishes that look like salads IMO are dangerous as if those greens are all wakame it is far too much

Emma JC
Find your vegan soulmate or just a friend. www.spiritualmatchmaking.com
 
I think this much to do about nothing.
Really, anyone who relies on FB for information had bigger things to worry about.

However nutritional deficiencies facing vegans is a real thing. and nothing new. Some of us deal with it by eating a varied and abundant WFPB diet. others monitor their diet and take some supplements.

Half the soy milk I consume is fortified.

And the iodine thing is real but a bit overstated. one of the reasons GB didn't require iodized salt was that its an island and the crops are close enough to the ocean to get iodine from the environment. Here in the US a lot of our cropland is well inland. And with monocultures and corporate industrial farming, well that just makes it worse.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: 4silva
I think this much to do about nothing.
Really, anyone who relies on FB for information had bigger things to worry about.

However nutritional deficiencies facing vegans is a real thing. and nothing new. Some of us deal with it by eating a varied and abundant WFPB diet. others monitor their diet and take some supplements.

Half the soy milk I consume is fortified.

And the iodine thing is real but a bit overstated. one of the reasons GB didn't require iodized salt was that its an island and the crops are close enough to the ocean to get iodine from the environment. Here in the US a lot of our cropland is well inland. And with monocultures and corporate industrial farming, well that just makes it worse.
I got a large pack of the roasted seaweed snacks, they're good just as is, but also in a fried rice, or a tofu or chickpea salad if you like that
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andy_T