Opinion: Dairy is just as bad or worse


Jul 15, 2017
Reaction score
People have this idea that it is better to eat dairy than beef, because the cow didn't die for the dairy, but that cow will be slaughtered when her milk production falls off and to keep the milk flowing she must be impregnated once per year and if the last calf she produced was a male, he has been killed already, either discarded or slaughtered immediately for bob veal or kept in a veal crate for a period of time to make regular veal.

So a cow has already died for the dairy, if her last calf was a male, and she herself will die someday for that dairy, because she will be of no use after she is spent so will then be made into hamburger.

Also, she has a comparatively long miserable life as a dairy cow, having her babies ripped from her year after year for three years, compared to a shorter slightly better life for a beef cow.

Sometimes, people who think dairy is less cruel than beef claim it is because in theory it is possible to let mother and child stay together and not kill either, and still get the milk.

However, the cow would give milk for less than a year, and then she would have to get pregnant again to keep the milk flowing. Without slaughter and without allowing predators to thin the herd, what would keep the population of breeding cows in check? Even in a hypothetical, idyllic setting, the cows would out breed their food source. So I don't see how slaughter free milk is possible, or how it is possible even in theory in an ideal setting to have milk for which a cow has not or will not die(d) to produce.

The only way I can see it being slaughter free is if you have milk for one year and then have all your cows spayed or neutered and keep them as pets for the next 20 years. And I don't see how that being possible in theory makes eating factory farmed dairy better than factory farmed beef, because cows die to produce both but factory farmed dairy cow suffer more.


Aug 3, 2019
Reaction score
I think it's more animal friendly to eat biological meat than to drink milk, at least they had a decent life prior to their death (too short, that is)
But most animals in the meat industry suffer too while alive and get killed in inhumane ways, which is only getting worse with the influx of Muslims in Europe and their halal ********. And the problem with biological meat is that you don't always know... You'll have to visit the farm to be sure the animals really have it good. A farm just outside of my hometown keeps cows for meat and they truly have it good. It's just a small group, the babies stay with their moms and they have a huge field of grass with their own lake in it. Now I personally still wouldn't eat meat even if animals had that much luxury while alive, eating dead animals in itself is just nope, the smell alone makes me sick now...

Animals in the dairy industry suffer no doubt, these cows are literally getting raped, by humans, just to get their babies stolen and get killed themselves when they get too old...

I'm kinda more okay with eggs, they lay them anyways (I mean, we breeded them like that, which is gross but good luck undoing that now) but I'm not okay with the way a lot of those chicken are kept and their brothers getting killed. I heard they even try to find a way to genetically manipulate chicken so there will only be females anymore. In a way that's good cause no more roosters will get killed but ******* with genes and hormones like that can never be healthy, I can't imagine it being healthy for the humans who eat those eggs either...
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
D Can i have your opinion on my vegan trainers? Products 1
SongHyeKyo What is your opinion about the side effect of vegatarian? General 1
G Media Vegan super strength - want your opinion please Marketplace 7
Indian Summer Health Issues What is your opinion on immunisations? Health & Body 47
Bite Size Vegan B12 On A Vegan Diet: The Doctor's Opinion Health & Body 6
beancounter Might and Magic series - Your opinion Lounge 0
A I Ate Dairy After Being Vegan For Over Two Years! Support 18
Indian Summer News Emissions from Big Dairy match those from entire UK Environment 1
R Dairy farms aren’t as Bad as Vegans Suggest. Animals 1
Lillibby Less anxiety since cutting out dairy? Health & Body 4
VeganForum Giving Up Dairy-Easier Than You Think! Health & Body 1
shyvas Vegan Food Brands that Sell Meat/Dairy Food & Drink 1
Lou News Plant-Based Butter Is Taking Over The Dairy Aisle Food & Drink 14
Lou Urge USDA To Drop Dairy From Recommendations! General 1
B Good dairy replacements? Transitioning 29
R Giving up dairy Support 19
R Giving up dairy Transitioning 12
Lou News Dairy Butter-Bad For The Planet Environment 0
Emma JC another dairy bankruptcy General 1
Z Non-dairy hi protein lo sugar yogurt hard to find General 9
A Vegan for 4 years and now I'm eating meat/dairy regularly. Transitioning 12
Vegan News News Dairy Farmer Goes Vegan After Industry Made Her Suicidal General 2
S Question Alpro dairy free custard Ask Us a Question! 3
Lou News Dairy and Disease General 0
M Question Are we responsible for deaths-Egg & dairy industries? Ask Us a Question! 12
TofuRobot Dairy industry is lobbying hard General 1
Lou Eliminating Dairy Saves Water General 10
Lou Baskin Robins Launches Non-Dairy Flavors! Food & Drink 1
S UK Non Dairy Skim Milk? General 11
S Non-dairy skim milk? Transitioning 12
KLS52 Malk ... Non Dairy Milk General 10
nobody Is vegan meat/dairy/eggs healthier than real? Health & Body 31
Indian Summer BBC: environmental impact of plant vs dairy milks Environment 1
H Dairy free cheese Food & Drink 11
TofuRobot Save bees to save dairy? General 2
Lou So delicious - five new flavors of frozen dairy desserts Products 4
Lou Hawaiian residents successfully shut down 2,000-acre dairy farm General 1
Queen of Strawberries Goat dairy industry vs. cow dairy industry General 15
Lou Big meat and dairy are heating up our planet Environment 2
Lou News updates on plant milks vs. dairy Food & Drink 3
J Dairy or chicken Transitioning 9
Indian Summer Taxing meat and dairy consumption General Discussion 3
Lou The manolo blahnik dairy Animals 2
Lou Floating dairy farm Animals 8
Lou Dairy farm turns to gofundme for survival Animals 0
P Breakfast tips (i don't like dairy replacements) Food & Drink 7
Lou Join the dairy free club General 0
R Pls Help-How dairy cattle are treated in the UK? Animals 11
shyvas US Walnut Products to Rival Meat/Dairy General 17
shyvas Ikea - Dairy Free Soft Serve Ice Cream General 6
Similar threads