Jewish Apple Cake Modifications

Dec 9, 2019
Reaction score
North Central Pennsylvania
I have been stumped over my grandmother's apple cake recipe, which I'd like to modify to make it vegan. Has anyone ever replaced FOUR eggs with flax eggs or Ener G? I want to be sure it'll work before I waste a bunch of staples and good apples. The original recipe has a dense, moist pound cake with tons of apples and cinnamon and I make it in a tube pan but,unfortunately,four eggs. Anything else I should add to replace some of the liquid? Aquafaba,maybe?
  • ❤
Reactions: Emma JC


Jan 1, 2020
Reaction score
Eggs are usually just binder and easily replaced with whatever you like, but with 4 eggs it makes me wonder whether the beaten eggs are the only source of leavening in the recipe. If that's the case, you're going to need something more than flax to get your cake to rise. I'd use Ener G, and I've never had it fail me.

Since you don't want to gamble, here's a vegan recipe for Jewish Apple Cake and you can compare your recipe to it for reassurance before you put in the effort. (I, too, dislike wasted time, effort and ingredients.)

Good luck!
  • 👍
Reactions: PTree15 and Emma JC


Super Moderator
Staff member
Jun 5, 2012
Reaction score
Somewhere in the South
It's baking powder that makes cakes rise not the eggs unless they are whisked. I make a Somerset style apple cake and replace the egg with extra plant based milk.

Emma JC

Jun 15, 2017
Reaction score
Aquafaba is also a good idea as it can fluff up the same as egg whites can. Maybe cut the recipe in half into two bowls and try some of each suggestion in each bowl and see which you prefer? I have been making my mom's raisin loaf recipe recently and gradually replacing some of the original ingredients with others, like almond flour for some of the white flour and ground flax for some of the white flour, and it turns out perfectly fine and there are no eggs in it at all. It is dense, as an apple cake would be and I'll bet whatever you use it will still taste awesome as it is the apples and spices that add the taste. Ground chia seeds are also a great alternative, mixed with warm water, of course. Grinding them first in a bullet makes a big difference and a 3/1 ratio of water/ground seeds works well and would add a bit of a poppy seed look.

Emma JC
  • 👍
Reactions: PTree15
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
shyvas News Rabbi Predicts Jewish Exodus - France General Discussion 8
M Some pretty cool vegan Apple Watch bands Marketplace 0
shyvas The Humble Apple Food & Drink 42
Indian Summer Computers Apple vs Google devices Science & Technology 0
Amy SF Computers The Everything Apple Thread Science & Technology 41
MadamSarcastra Man-Machine French man smashes items in Apple Store Science & Technology 1
Amy SF Apple Cider Vinegar Food & Drink 5
Katrina What goes well with apple? Food & Drink 6
beancounter An apple a day does not keep the doctor away - really Health & Body 3
shyvas Vegan Cream of Butternut Squash & Apple Soup Soups 1
Vee1 Vegan Lemon, apple, carrot loaf Cakes & Bakes 4
beancounter Another possible scam email involving Apple Science & Technology 5
shyvas Vegan Farmhouse Apple Cake British Bakes 7
shyvas Vegan Mincemeat & Apple Tart Holiday/Seasonal/Festive 0
shyvas Vegan Mulled Apple Juice Holiday/Seasonal/Festive 15
KLS52 APPLE TREE Home & Garden 10
Werewolf Girl Music First Listen: Fiona Apple, 'The Idler Wheel...' Media & Entertainment 6
K UK Looking For Eggless Cake Recipes! Transitioning 25
peacefulveglady Cake ideas Food & Drink 7
A Raw blueberry cake Recipes 0
Cherrytreerosebush Does anybody know a vegan nut-free biscuit/cake recipe? Food & Drink 3
Mark Mywordz Easy cake recipe Recipes 3
Damo Vegan Cake Food & Drink 8
Damo Perfect World Taste Of Carrot Cake Ice Cream Food & Drink 2
kim1984 Cocoa Layer Cake with Cashew Cream Frosting Food & Drink 3
Calliegirl Veganized Entenmann's Coffee Cake Food & Drink 2
shyvas Vegan Chocolate & Spice Cake Cakes & Bakes 0
SuicideBlonde Vegan Orange, Cardamom, Spice Cake Cakes & Bakes 11
shyvas Vegan Chocolat Sponge Cake Cakes & Bakes 2
IamJen Vegan Absurdly Easy Chocolate Cake Cakes & Bakes 11
Hannah1 Favorite Cake Recipe Food & Drink 9
Underdog Vegan Frosting Ideas (Chocolate Cake base) Food & Drink 7
CrazyCatLady Betty Crocker cake mix Food & Drink 3
Indian Summer Vegan Dense and moist carrot cake Cakes & Bakes 5
alligatortears Vegan Gingerbread Cake Cakes & Bakes 9
shyvas Vegan Mincemeat Crumble Cake Holiday/Seasonal/Festive 6
shyvas Vegan Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake Cakes & Bakes 3
Pickle Juice Birthday Cake! Festivities & Special Occasions 12
Alice-Bee Vegan Chocolate cake Cakes & Bakes 13
Veggiemama Vegan Scandinavian Almond Cake Cakes & Bakes 0

Similar threads